On Friday morning 20 November, the SRVU, together with Stop de Oorlogskoorts, urged VU students to walk out of class in a national protest against the militarisation of Dutch society. At a time when Russia is waging a full-scale war against Ukraine and increasing hybrid warfare across Europe, this protest is painfully tone-deaf – and possibly dangerous to our peace.
Slogans like “Fight for our future, not their wars!”, “They want to prepare us for war. We want a future”, and “They (…) refuse to work for peace in Europe” are flying around social media, urging VU students to walk out of class to fight for their future. While these slogans capture real frustration about the state of the world, they miss the geopolitical reality in which we live – and some of them unintentionally echo the narratives hand-crafted by Moscow.
Let us establish some baseline facts. After invading and occupying parts of Ukraine in 2014, Russia began its full-scale invasion and war of aggression with the ultimate goal of conquering Kyiv in early 2022. You can criticise European foreign policy on many fronts, and none of us should romanticise war. Yet Europe’s determination to defend international law and democracy in Ukraine is clear. Following the invasion, European countries came to an uncomfortable realisation: Russia does not want peace; it wants Ukraine, by any means necessary. To safeguard democracy and the rule of law, we must help defend Ukraine – and ourselves.
This is precisely why European states, including the Netherlands, have begun rebuilding their defence capabilities. Increased defence spending and societal preparedness are entirely reactive, triggered by Russia’s invasion of a sovereign country and its ongoing provocations against Europe. With this in mind, it becomes impossible for me to accept the protesters’ claim that the Dutch government is “stealing their future” simply by investing in defence, or that “they refuse to work for peace in Europe”. While debates over how we fund housing, education, and defence are valid, framing deterrence and defence itself as “warmongering” ignores who actually created this crisis. If anyone is “stealing our future” or refusing to work for peace in Europe, it is Moscow – not The Hague.
This causal link is unequivocal: Russian imperialism forced Europe to rearm for its own protection. Yet Moscow frequently creates a narrative of the opposite being true: that European defence alliances are to blame for the war and not their own imperialism. This is a big part of Moscow’s strategy against the West: to create a false sense of reality that weakens our resolve and resilience from within.
To those on campus who oppose these defensive measures, I have three simple questions: how do we defend Ukraine, Europe, and the Netherlands if we don’t have the ability to do so? And if we refuse to help Ukraine resist an imperialist aggressor, what stops Moscow from doing the same to Estonia? Finland? Finally, what is our realistic alternative to deterrence when Russia has shown it answers dialogue with tanks?
Instead of relying on catchy slogans, we must confront what the actual alternative to deterrence is. My plea to fellow VU students is simple: Demand a fair, affordable, and sustainable future from our governments without ignoring the security threats at our doorstep. Critically ask yourself who actually benefits when European students march against their own defence. Above all, if you claim to stand for resistance against oppression, stand with Ukraine – because right now, Ukrainians are not only fighting for their own survival, but they are defending our democracy and freedom too.